Manufacturing jobs aren’t coming back, and that’s ok.
I am absolutely gobsmacked by the number of people on Twitter, on the news, and in the administration who are touting a huge comeback of manufacturing factories and the jobs associated with them.
These people are living in the past. We are a globalist country, and to hide from that fact doesn’t makes us great. It makes us stupid.
Even if a company decided to bring back a factory, how many jobs do you really think it will produce? Sure, there will be short term jobs involved in the construction and manufacture of the robots that will be working in the plant. But then what?
That’s right, automation and technology has advanced by leaps and bounds since the manufacturing heyday between the 40s and 70s. There are actually “lights out” factories today. These factories utilize robots for all of the assembly, warehousing, and shipping and only require a small handful of people to monitor the robots. And by small handful, I mean like 20 people at most. These are not the human capital intensive jobs people are imagining they will be. One plant with 20 people isn’t going to support a community.
Another fact that isn’t being discussed is that there are currently around 400 THOUSAND manufacturing jobs that are unfilled in the US.
I grew up in Akron. I’ve seen first hand the devastation wrought by loss of rubber and steel factories. I’m not insensitive to that. But I also know that my grandfather died of lung cancer from working in a plastic sheeting company. My great-grandfather retired from BF Goodrich. I do know that both of them wanted better for their own kids. They encouraged them to do other, better, less harsh, dangerous, backbreaking work. When did we stop wanting better work for future generations? Why are we looking to the past for solutions that just won’t work for today?
For about 15 years prior to 2020 & COVID, I had wondered frequently why more office jobs were not more popular and readily available. Finally, COVID forced millions of office workers to work from home and businesses adapted fairly quickly because of technology – we already had laptops, cellphones, online video conferencing, and nearly all programs we use for work can be accessed online with your login. Aside from the terrifying aspect of dying from COVID, I was quite fine with everyone being at home. I was fortunate my kids were in high school at the time, so I did not have the added issues of taking care of little ones while also working. But even for those who did, they now no longer had stressful commutes. They could take breaks without worrying about some micromanager having a fit about it. They could eat a healthy lunch. They had time to pursue more things they actually wanted – making bread, crafts, or other hobbies. Was it perfect? No. Could we have continued it and refined it? Absolutely!
Our leaders are failing America because they work incrementally. Part of that is because the electorate doesn’t keep the same party in place long enough to effect a lot of substantial change. The leadership who does run tries to appeal to “moderate” voters, and we end up with the status quo of two steps forward and three steps back. For those of us who want real progress, this is infuriating.
We are in the 21st century and people want to bring back jobs from 60 years ago! We need bold leadership that adapts and embraces and pioneers what work could and should look like today. We all have access to technology and we’ve seen it popup everywhere – at the self-checkout at the store, at the kiosk and app ordering at McDonald’s, at the little table console that enables you to pay your bill electronically at the restaurant, and more. These advancements provide convenience and, let’s face it, they cut back on the need for people. But is that necessarily bad?
I don’t think it is. We have touted ourselves as the greatest country in the world for far too long and yet still fail miserably to actually be that in reality. By just believing it, we have failed to bring about any changes or progress that would actually make us the greatest country in the world. We are not the happiest, most educated, or even most healthy country. We lag far behind other developed countries on these and other metrics. It’s time to own it and finally do something about it.
So what could work look like for people in the US?
- Office work is now completely remote. Companies no longer have the overhead of office buildings, utilities, and a lot of office equipment and supplies.
- Highly automated factories with techs and engineers trained to build, fix, or program the robots.
- Shorter work weeks! When you are hired to work, you are agreeing to complete X tasks. Since we’ve evolved and have technology available to us, those tasks can be automated or done much more quickly than even 30 years ago. What should it matter if you complete your work in 20 hours or 40 hours? As long as it gets done!
- Salary over hourly. Due to the work agreement – X tasks are done as agreed regardless of the number of hours in a week, the completed work product has the same value and time should not be a factor in pay. If you value the work now at $65,000 a year, then it should still have that value even if someone is only working 25 hours to provide it. And let’s face it, how many hours a week does anyone work in an office really?
Do other things need to happen for this to work? Absolutely, and none of them involve tanking the stock market!
- Universal Healthcare – let’s finally do it and join the other THIRTY-THREE (33) developed countries in providing a real, valuable service to our citizens. These countries have years of data that we can learn from so that we can architect a system that works for the US. We already have the Medicare claims system (hi, former medical billing manager here) which has always been one of the most efficiently run programs. But did you know that even after you’ve been paying into this your whole life, you still have a monthly premium and an annual deductible? On top of that, Medicare only pays 80% of the allowed amount – leaving you with the remaining 20% or you can pay for a supplemental secondary insurance. Yes, we have Medicare Advantage programs that offer different, possibly better coverage options but the government is handing money over to private insurance companies that already screw over consumers way too much. Using the money we already have in the Medicare fund, Medicaid, CHAMPVA & CHAMPUS (military medical care) we can create a better system that provides citizens with healthcare from birth to death that they don’t have to fundraise to pay for, or risk bankruptcy if they have a lot of medical care needs, a long hospitalization or something else. Because people will be able to be covered from birth to death and get the regular routine care & treatment they need, diseases will be spotted earlier, improving the likelihood of survival and giving us better outcomes; people can continuously take the medications they may need and not have to choose between groceries or utilities or medication. Why the heck are we living like that in the supposed richest country in the world anyway? But I digress. Within a decade we would start to see health improvements and decreases in overall healthcare costs. This is without a doubt one of the best investments we can make in our society. Additionally, this would encourage more entrepreneurial endeavors as people wouldn’t have to be worried about losing their employment-based insurance any longer.
- Universal Basic Income or UBI – there have been multiple pilot programs that demonstrate that this always has a net positive effect. UBI is not an amount to cover every living expense, but it is enough to keep people out of poverty or from losing their home if they lose their job or deal with a health crisis. UBI allows people to save, go to college or obtain other jobs training, start a business, engage in a hobby, get a gym membership, enjoy some upgrades in their lives, etc. Overall, it enables people to get their needs met, the basics of which are food, shelter, and safety. UBI could help someone leave an abusive relationship or enable someone to save and put their kids through college or finally take that Caribbean vacation they always wanted. We have a right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. For too long, we’ve deliberately kept people in poverty or just barely above, instead of enabling people to really have the ability and opportunity to pursue what would make them happy or do work they find deeply meaningful. Again, this is not about giving someone all the money they need, but enough that they aren’t always living life on the brink. Nearly half of Americans live paycheck to paycheck! Something that should be unacceptable to all of us just on a moral basis, but should certainly be unacceptable to any country that claims it is the richest country in the world.
- Increased wages – both universal healthcare and UBI would lead to higher wages. Why? Because if someone has a safety net, they will no longer be stuck in a job they no longer find fulfilling or are unhappy at for myriad reasons. Employers would be incentivized to pay more to keep the employees they need since they know that they are no longer stuck due to either wage loss or health insurance.
I want to see bold, loud leadership touting the future of work and the betterment of our society and explaining how they will do it, with a timeline and everything. These things are absolutely achievable, we need only to find the will. That and to overcome everybody’s “oh that’s socialism/communism” objections that are meaningless since most people toss the terms around and don’t even know what they mean.
I want to live like the Jetsons, not like the Flintstones and I really don’t know why we all don’t want that.








